SECRET KEEPING
Overcoming Hidden Habits and Addictions
By
John Howard Prin
A self-help guide to gaining freedom and
control over the secrets that make us sick
Book Highlights
All of us keep a secret now and then, but at least one out of fifteen people are chronic Secret Keepers. They are persons whose secrets have power over them and make them misbehave, become sick, or violate others.
Such is the case with hard-working professionals or family men and women, high-functioning on one level but in bondage to deeply held secrets on another. We read about these folks who steal hours away from their productive lives in the daily news:
- A university professor of religious studies who is found with more than 4,200 Internet photos of child porn on his work computer
- A hard-working mother with three children who hides bottles of vodka in the laundry room, then binges when the kids are at school.
- An elected legislator who files for bankruptcy from gambling debts and the public learns of his taking off hours from work weekly to visit casinos, wearing clever disguises.
- A homeowner who allows 400 cats to overrun her entire household until the stench from years of undisposed urine and feces prompts neighbors to report her residence to public health authorities.
- A PTA chairperson who arrives late to important meetings because she can’t leave the house until checking to make sure her stove is turned off dozens of times and who even turns off the water taps extra tightly so her pets won’t go crazy listening to a constant dripping sound.
Each of these troubled people lives a double life because their unhealthy secrets overpower them. Now think of the 80 million similar Secret Keepers worldwide* who steal hours away from their public lives to act out their secret behaviors or passions, sometimes for decades, but who never get found out. You will meet:
- Tracy, a bulimic
- Brad, a pathological gambler
- Kevin, a cross-dresser
- Lila, a shoplifter
- Shelly, wife of an exhibitionist
- Earl, an incest perpetrator
- Mitch, executive in credit card debt
- Caroline, captive to Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD)
- And myself, a once-secret drinker and….
Secret Keeping is a guide to self-awareness that assists readers to rid themselves of double lives, those unhealthy and disabling habits of double-mindedness that plague so many—and, instead, to live liberated lives of whole-mindedness. Its healing messages provide practical stepping stones to wholeness and emotional recovery for anyone living a double life of secret activities.
This book is intended for:
- People who have secrets that make them unhealthy or unhappy.
- Practicing Secret Keepers looking for solutions to the suffering caused by the double-minded choices of their secret lives.
- Persons living with a Secret Keeper, frequently suspicious and weary, who are seeking encouragement and effective coping skills.
- Professionals in the counseling, social work, and pastoral fields who deal with secret-keeping behaviors and who will use this book’s ideas, theories, and practical advice to help their clients.
Table of Contents
PART 1
The Self Divided
Problems & Consequences
Introduction: Confessions of a Liberated Secret Keeper
Chapter 1: Who Are Secret Keepers?
Chapter 2: What Are Unhealthy Secret Habits?
Chapter 3: How Secret Habits Seduce Us
Chapter 4: Where the Actions We Hide Stay Hidden
Chapter 5: When Nobody is Looking, Who Are You?
Chapter 6: Maximizing Pleasure, Minimizing Pain
Chapter 7: The Quest for Authenticity
Chapter 8: When Secret Keeping Goes Too Far
PART 2
The Journey Toward Wholeness
Solutions & Rewards
Introduction: The Freedom of Recovery
Chapter 9: I Give Up, Help
Chapter 10: Where Is My Inspiration?
Chapter 11: Discovering Who I Genuinely Am
Chapter 12: Here's the Real Me
Chapter 13: The World and My Place in It
Chapter 14: My Authenticity in a Messy World
Chapter 15: Transformation From Deep Within
Chapter 16: My Recovery From Today On
If interested contact John Prin
Introduction
Everyone keeps secrets.
Some people who keep secrets do not feel guilty, others do.
It's the second kind of people who keep secrets, those who feel guilt or shame, that Secret Keeping is written for. In my career as a therapist and counselor, I've come to call these clients Secret Keepers®. Secret Keepers can be anyone from a housewife hiding vodka bottles from her family to compulsive gamblers, food addicts, cyber sex fanatics, or anyone else who is secretly hiding behind the mask of a double life.
Sometimes people just daydream about a taboo fantasy world, not acting on their thoughts. This is secret-keeping® in its mildest form. If this describes you, relax. It's static, benign—not a problem. This book will help you but you're not in any major trouble. Think of yourself as a human being like everybody else, and that you have your life together and under control.
Other Secret Keepers go beyond thinking about their fantasies to living them out. They willingly take risks and consciously push boundaries that move them in a negative direction towards something that is, or will become, a problem for themselves and others. This is secret-keeping in its active form. It's dynamic, volatile—and highly problematic. Individuals like these stretch ethical, moral, and relational boundaries in search of something missing in their lives, often to escape some pain or hurt. If you find yourself in this category, Secret Keeping will help you understand why you need to rethink your secret-keeping strategy(ies) and how to examine your options, including seeking outside help. It will open the door to hope—the hope of living freely without deception, lies, alibis, guilt or shame.
Still other kinds of people act outside accepted ethical, moral, and relational limits; they break the law. They willingly take illegal risks and commit crimes that endanger or damage themselves, others, and society. This is secret-keeping in its criminal or psychotic form. It's malignant, destructive—and highly injurious. In this category are two types of individual: the decent, regular sort of person whose secrecy makes them cross the line into crime or psychosis, and the hardened, antisocial sort of career criminal such as a serial rapist or murderer. This book will deal only marginally with the latter level of sex offender and killer. What's essential to realize is that secret-keeping, in all of its forms, involves some degree of criminal thinking along with risks, thrills, and multiple kinds of harm. The likelihood of slipping down the slippery slope for any Secret Keeper—from static to dynamic to malignant—always exists.
As you read Secret Keeping, you will see that it describes people with good hearts and curious minds who are seeking, many times inappropriately, wholeness and fulfillment. It features everyday working adults with families, homes, jobs, and responsibilities. They may be in the static or active stages of "stealing hours" from their public lives headed toward the malignant stage. By participating secretly in hidden habits they realize are shameful or stigmatizing, they risk stepping outside their public lives fully aware that, if anybody knew, their good standing and reputation in the community would diminish or be destroyed.
Confessions of a Liberated Secret Keeper
I speak from both my personal and professional encounters with secret-keeping. From age eleven to 51, I lived two parallel lives. Based solely on outward appearances, I looked normal, made a good impression, and was a high-functioning teenager as well as adult. The volcanic drama of my hidden addictive life, however, and the ways it gained control over me, were another story altogether.
My decades as an active Secret Keeper certainly made me ill. Gradually the ways I kept secrets and the resulting pattern of living a double life of lies, cover-ups, and addictions (what I later came to call “secret keeping”) subverted any hope of living a fulfilling life. But I’ve discovered I was hardly alone. In time I learned the simple truth:
We are as sick as our secrets.
This inner story that I alone experienced—and how everybody was fooled—is only half of the story, though. The even bigger story is that my life mirrors the experience of thousands of other people, a number of whom you will meet in these pages.
In Secret Keeping, you will see how my own and others' double lives remained hidden behind the masks that everyone around us observed. In my case, the forty years that I lived in two worlds, ricocheting between public respectability and private temptations, were years I would never choose to repeat. By my thirties, I was addicted to drugs, plagued by an ulcer, in bondage to philandering and pornography, and living in a parallel universe haunted by suicidal and homicidal urges. On a chilly, windswept November afternoon in 1977, my wayward life collapsed and I faced the gut-wrenching moment of almost ending my life.
Ultimately, these "stolen" years taught me invaluable lessons that eventually led to the rewards of whole-mindedness. Others reached similar low points in their lives: hospitalizations for eating disorders, financial ruin from credit card debt, jail time for shoplifting, arrests for sexual crimes, and career crashes from compulsive gambling and extra-marital affairs.
In my current professional role as a counselor, I’ve heard numerous stories of secret-keeping from clients who told me about their double lives. I've unearthed numerous ways people keep secrets and become sick from their destructive habits. The clients I counsel often feel sabotaged by their self-defeating habits and end up hating their split reality. They are among the more than 20,000,000 Americans** who get trapped in hidden double lives yet still function in their jobs, in their homes, and with their families—and they walk among us every day.
My counseling work has centered on developing effective therapies to help people struggling with the tensions of a secret life. In short, my journey to wholeness has served to not only unlock the secrets that made me sick, but the secrets that make others sick as well. Eventually I discovered one of the underlying problems that had disabled so many and prevented them from fulfilling their life’s destiny: a history of wounded, negative emotions lived out unconsciously in their adult lives. Today I devote my waking efforts to assisting troubled individuals to free themselves from the detours, deceptions, and dead ends of secret-keeping, so they too can live their best lives. Secret Keeping: From Living Double Lives to Freedom is meant to make this motivating knowledge available to thousands more than I can serve personally.
The simple truth? We are as sick as our secrets … but there’s hope!
If interested contact John Prin
Emotional health for Secret Keepers means living in a balanced
state of being where two worlds merge and become one-double-mindedness
ceases and becomes whole-mindedness. The book presents the reader with eight traits, or splintered
mindsets, of a Secret Keeper:
-
Acting one way
while feeling another
-
Placing appearance
first, reality second
-
Living from the
outside, in
-
Getting your way
any way possible
-
Maximizing pleasure
and minimizing pain
-
Considering oneself
first and others last
- Stealing hours
doing what is required to feel better
-
Walking a tightrope
between two opposing worlds.
Continuum of Secrets
© 2006 John Howard Prin
Excerpt from
Secret Keeping:
Overcoming Hidden Habits and Addictions
(from New World Library, July 2006)
This chart spells out some basic distinctions that apply to the kinds of secrets that functioning adults tend to keep. The continuum gradually came into being the more I counseled clients with disabling addictions and depression/anxiety disorders. In brief, I learned that "secrets are pathology." Keep in mind that the first and second categories, Simple Secrets and Silent Secrets, are typical of human beings in general and not the concern of this book nor its readers.
None to Less Harm |
More to Much Harm |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
Simple Secrets |
Silent Secrets |
Secret Keeping |
Criminal-Psychotic Behavior |
(everybody has) |
(dark & taboo but passive) |
(acting out ethical and moral wrongs
but not illegal) |
(arrestable offenses
or hospitalizations) |
BENIGN |
STATIC |
DYNAMIC |
MALIGNANT |
1. “Simple” secrets are those that emerge from isolated, rare events, the kind of harmless mistakes or lapses in judgment that seldom require self-disclosure or therapy—often memories from childhood or adolescence. A young student peeks at her classmate’s test answers or an underage driver takes his dad’s car out for a joy ride, but nobody ever finds out. Indirectly secrets like these open the individual to dualistic thinking that can develop and take hold.
2. “Silent” secrets are those that become ingrained thoughts or attitudes which can risk one’s mental health. Fantasies that remain in a person's mind and do not lead to acting out behavior fit here. So do "acts of deceptive omission" like the story of three college fraternity brothers who got drunk and went boating together. One fell overboard and the other two jumped in to save him. The two drowned but the first survived. He felt intense guilt and concealed any hint about their drinking at the young men’s funerals, and years later he feels exhausted, dirty inside, and burdened by (A) having caused his pals’ deaths and (B) deceived their families. One act (getting drunk) led to another (falling overboard while boating) that compounded into a tragedy (two drownings) that resulted in a cover-up (concealing truth from the victims’ parents) that became years of torment from silently keeping the truth secret.
3. “Secret-keeping” goes one step further and includes acting out, more specifically the habits or rituals which can lead to risking one’s safety, health, or sanity and that of others; the kind of harmful patterns that make one sick and that benefit from disclosure and therapy. Secrets in this category include behavior patterns and rituals that lead to stealing hours away from one’s “normal life” to feel better. These hidden acts stretch, and eventually break, ethical/moral standards and relational boundaries but do not cross the line into breaking the law or psychosis. The head pastor of a leading-edge evangelical metro church engaged in a furtive, ongoing extramarital affair of eight years which broke ethical, moral, and biblical rules. His secret-keeping led to divorce, career exile, months of counseling for family members, and news headlines describing harmful consequences to thousands of parishioners. Nevertheless, he was never hauled off in handcuffs nor did he face court charges or serve time in jail.
4. "Crime/Psychosis." Secrets in this category may include a mixture of secrets from the previous categories, but acting out violates legal boundaries/standards thereby making them crimes punishable by law, such as shoplifting, or serious psychological pathology (psychosis). Sara Jane Olson fits the criminal definition. After evading arrest for attempted murder in California as a fiery member of the rebellious Symbionese Liberation Army in 1975, she lived 24 years inconspicuously as a suburban mother and housewife in St. Paul, Minnesota until being discovered and sent to prison. A psychotic person is an individual who loses touch with reality and becomes captive to paranoia, delusions, and hallucinations, leading to hospitalization or institutionalization. The characters who kept secrets in stories like that of Billy in movies like One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest or the kidnapper in Silence of the Lambs fit this description.
Remember that the categories Simple Secrets and Silent Secrets are typical of human beings in general and not examined in Secret Keeping. While we may encounter examples of each category in our lives, and while some fit the category of Family of Origin secrets, these levels of secrets do not cross the line into the third and fourth categories, Secret Keeping and Criminal-Psychotic Behavior, which are the focus of this book.
Let's make clear what secret-keeping is NOT:
It is not the kind of secrets kept by adults who hold Family of Origin childhood secrets—memories of abusive home lives or their parents' stigmatizing secrets. Such secrets surely may influence current adult beliefs and behavior, and may require therapy, but they fit into the Silent Secrets category, because the secrets were somebody else's and in the past.
Nor is secret-keeping the kind of secrets kept by citizens oppressed by tyrannical governments such as the Nazis or Soviet Communists or Idi Amin. These victims' secrets were kept to avoid capture, prison, torture, and death. Included in this kind of secrets are those of paid professional spies such as CIA or FBI agents. These have to do with political or governmental conflicts, not the interpersonal relationships or inner universe of Secret Keepers.
Nor is secret-keeping the kind of secrets we keep from ourselves. In psychological lingo, these are the result of repression. Unlike conscious concealment, which is the intentional withholding of shameful or negative personal information from others, the term repression means "keeping painful thoughts and impulses out of our conscious awareness." Below is a definition on that spells out these enigmatic forces in one sentence:
Secret Keepers live in a parallel universe
based on the intentional concealment of what is
shameful or discreditable beyond the limits of privacy.*
* Chapter Two of Secret Keeping is devoted to the distinctions between secrecy and
privacy.
Profile
of a Secret Keeper
Secret Keepers steal hours away from their "normal" lives to
act out private behaviors, rituals, and fantasies, especially
whenever their secrets overpower them. By their very cleverness
they elude getting caught-thus only seldom appearing in tomorrow's
headlines or ending up in police custody. The people closest to
them may suspect their excuses or alibis at times, and think to
themselves "how odd or eccentric they are," or "they seem lost in a private
world of their own." But hard evidence almost never surfaces and
telltale clues, if there are any, go noticed.
Secret Keepers, even when they function smoothly in their public
lives, carry with them the concealed secrets about themselves
nobody knows about-not wife, not parents, not siblings, not friends,
not the boss. And so they live a double life continuously, whether
stealing hours to act out or not. Secret Keeperspush ethical, moral, and relational
boundaries but are generally too smart or too clever to overstep
legal boundaries (with rare exceptions). They may skirt the law
but hardly ever get arrested or labeled as criminals. They may
be alcoholics or drug addicts, but not the obvious ones who abuse
openly and deceive no one. In all, about 80 million Secret Keepers
worldwide walk among us. Men and women, young and old, individuals
of every race and nationality, they are human beings with two
opposing selves existing in one body.
Projecting a wholesome self for all to see and approve of, they
carefully hide their secret selves for none to discover and denounce.
Meanwhile, the competing selves within them wage war and, over
time, wear down the person until a crisis (still another secret
unknown to everybody, of course) threatens their sanity. Unavoidably,
then, their emotional mind battles their rational mind and the
decision to disclose intimate knowledge to somebody builds pressure
inside them, wreaking daily suffering until they surrender or "do something."
If interested contact John Prin
Secret Keeping
The reader will discover in each person's story-some after years
or decades of
stealing hours and hiding unhealthy behaviors- the various ways
they struggled to merge their inner and outer worlds into one.
The types of process these individuals went through to confront
Secret-Keeping include: seeking
counseling, attending support groups, claiming scripture, participating
in healing services, changing thinking patterns, identifying core
emotional/identity beliefs, making amends, and other12-step/recovery/spiritual
measures.
John Howard Prin, LADC
Licensed Alcohol & Drug Counselor
Minneapolis, Minnesota
* Author's calculation based on US Census data for 2000 divided by the current agreed-upon SAMSHA percentage of Americans with addictive disorders.
** Author's estimated calculation based on US Census data and SAMSHA statistics.
|